HOME |  JOIN |  CULT MOVIES | COMPETITIONS | ADVERTISE |  CONTACT US |  ABOUT US
 
 
Newest Reviews
Unseen, The
Tonight She Comes
Chasing the Dragon
Into the Forest
Limehouse Golem, The
Frankenstein '80
Good Time
Bucket of Blood, A
Detroit
Hide and Seek
What Happened to Monday
River Wild, The
Veteran
Slumber Party '57
Juliette, or Key of Dreams
Summertime Killer
Sweet Virginia
Ben & Arthur
Your Name
Red Hot Shot, The
New World
Trick Baby
Weapons of Death
Second Best Secret Agent in the Whole Wide World, The
Kills on Wheels
Strait-Jacket
This Man is Dangerous
Burning Paradise
Away
Mistress of the Apes
   
 
Newest Articles
Apocalypse 80s UK: Threads and When the Wind Blows
Movie Flop to Triumphant TV Revival: Twin Peaks and The League of Gentlemen
Driving Force: The Golden Age of American Car Chases
Madness in his Method: Jim Carrey and Andy Kaufman
Music, Love and Flowers: Monterey Pop on Blu-ray
The Melville Mood: His Final Two Films on The Melville Collection Blu-ray
Always Agnès: 3 from The Varda Collection Blu-ray
Re: Possession of Vehicles - Killer Cars, Trucks and a Vampire Motorcycle
The Whicker Kicker: Whicker's World Vols 5&6 on DVD
The Empress, the Mermaid and the Princess Bride: Three 80s Fantasy Movies
   
 
  Murder by Decree Right Royal RumpusBuy this film here.
Year: 1979
Director: Bob Clark
Stars: Christopher Plummer, James Mason, David Hemmings, Susan Clark, Anthony Quayle, John Gielgud, Frank Finlay, Donald Sutherland, Geneviève Bujold, Chris Wiggins, Tedde Moore, Peter Jonfield, Roy Lansford, Catherine Kessler, Ron Pember, June Brown, Ken Jones
Genre: Thriller, Historical
Rating:  5 (from 2 votes)
Review: At London's Royal Opera House, the famed detective Sherlock Holmes (Christopher Plummer) and his faithful companion Dr. Watson (James Mason) are out for the evening, though Holmes is growing impatient with the amount of time it is taking the Prince to arrive so the the entertainment can begin. Eventually the Prince deigns to enter the Royal box, but the reception is not entirely a welcome one as the audience in the Gods make no secret of their displeasure with him. Watson is shocked, and rallies the others to drown out the jeers and boos, but as this is going on a murder is being committed which the crimefighting duo will be drawn into solving...

There's a message during the end credits of this film that proudly announces that its plotline is based on the latest theories about the identity of Jack the Ripper, for that is who Holmes and Watson are pitted against here. They had faced him before in a different screen adaptation, A Study in Terror, but the concept proved irresistable and producer-director Bob Clark came up with a film that was pretty lavish in its depiction of Victorian London. So why did Murder by Decree come across as a big budget television special? Was it because Arthur Conan Doyle's creation belonged on the small screen?

More likely it was because the plot was not really opened up and tended to take place in locations that were not above the money of the B.B.C. or I.T.V., and the overall impression is that a lot more imagination than the simple "Sherlock Holmes meets Jack the Ripper" way in to the story was necessary to make the drama and thrills take off and fly. Clark had proven himself adept at suspense before, but here his efforts seemed hampered by John Hopkins' stuiffy script, with only Plummer really putting in the work to bring some life to the production.

Unfortunately, he came across as miscast (Peter O'Toole, the original choice, would have been more interesting), and the attempts to render a compassionate Holmes are a little embarrassing. When our hero visits a poor soul (Genevieve Bujold) banished to an asylum as part of a huge conspiracy, he ends up in tears and flinging himself at the establishment's director in rage, not exactly the manner in which most people want their Sherlock to behave. Plummer also gets to prove his man of action credentials in a near-climactic tussle that would not be out of place in one of the regular James Bond movies.

Although it's a neat idea, I wonder how good a match the classic detective and the real life serial killer are, for they are at odds with each other. The reason the Ripper endures in both history and fiction is that he was never caught and therefore comes with a lot of baggage about nineteenth century social hypocrisy, the failings of the authorities and plain and simple chills. Holmes on the other hand always solved his cases, and so here has to be crowbarred into a plot where he has to pretend he has not uncovered the scheming that brought the killings to prominence and has to keep his mouth shut, all less than satisfying. Not only that, but every male guest star is saddled with some remarkable wigs and facial furniture to act through, which can be a distraction. Murder by Decree is a nice try, but does not do justice to either real life or fiction. Music by Paul Zaza and Carl Zittrer.
Reviewer: Graeme Clark

 

This review has been viewed 3354 time(s).

As a member you could Rate this film

 

Bob Clark  (1941 - 2007)

American born, Canadian-based writer, producer and director with a varied career, he rarely stopped working in the industry from his 1970s horror Children Shouldn't Play with Dead Things onwards, with cult classics like chiller Deathdream, Black Christmas (the first of the North American slasher cycle), Murder by Decree (a Sherlock Holmes mystery), sex comedy Porky's and its sequel, and A Christmas Story (a cult comedy that has become a seasonal favourite) all winning fans. He was responsible for such derided films as Rhinestone and the Baby Geniuses movies as well. At the time of his death in a car crash he was working on a remake of ...Dead Things.

 
Review Comments (0)


Untitled 1

Login
  Username:
 
  Password:
 
   
 
Forgotten your details? Enter email address in Username box and click Reminder. Your details will be emailed to you.
   

Latest Poll
Who's the best?
Robin Askwith
Mark Wahlberg
   
 
   

Recent Visitors
Graeme Clark
Enoch Sneed
Andrew Pragasam
Paul Shrimpton
  Rachel Franke
Jason Cook
Darren Jones
Keith Rockmael
   

 

Last Updated: