Newest Reviews
Call to Spy, A
Other Lamb, The
Every Time I Die
Lynn + Lucy
Honest Thief
Blood and Money
Rose: A Love Story
Antrum: The Deadliest Film Ever Made
Om Dar-B-Dar
Silencing, The
J.R. 'Bob' Dobbs and the Church of SubGenius
Dick Johnson is Dead
Legacy of Lies
I Am Woman
Alien Addiction
Dare, The
South Terminal
Little Monsters
Yield to the Night
My Zoe
Young Playthings
End of Summer
Times of Harvey Milk, The
Perfectly Normal Family, A
Honeymoon Phase, The
One Summer
Bird Island
Devil to Pay, The
Lost in London
Divorce Italian Style
Newest Articles
Confessions of a Porn Star: Adult Material on DVD
They're Still Not Sure It is a Baby: Eraserhead on Blu-ray
Werewolves are Real: Dog Soldiers on Digital
Rose: A Love Story - Producers April Kelley and Sara Huxley Interview
Phone Phreak: 976-EVIL on Blu-ray
Living the Nightmare: Dementia on Blu-ray
Becky and The Devil to Pay: Ruckus and Lane Skye Interview
Big Top Bloodbath: Circus of Horrors on Blu-ray
A Knock on the Door at 4 O'clock in the Morning: The Strangers on Blu-ray
Wives of the Skies: Honey Lauren Interview
To Catch a Thief: After the Fox on Blu-ray
Tackling the Football Film: The Arsenal Stadium Mystery on Blu-ray
Film Noir's Golden Couple: This Gun for Hire on Blu-ray
The Doctor Who Connection: Invasion on Blu-ray
Hill's Angles: Benny Hill and Who Done It? on Blu-ray
Big Willie Style: Keep It Up Downstairs on Blu-ray
Walt's Vault: 5 Cult Movies on Disney+
Paradise Lost: Walkabout on Blu-ray
Buster Makes Us Feel Good: Buster Keaton - 3 Films (Volume 3) on Blu-ray
Network On Air: Nights In with ABC 3 - Don't Go Away - I Could Do with a Bit of Cheer Now!
What Use is Grief to a Horse? Equus on Blu-ray
For God's Sake Strap Yourselves Down: Flash Gordon on 4K UHD Collector's Edition
Party Hard: Bill & Ted's Excellent Adventure on Blu-ray
Network On Air: Nights In with ABC 2 - Your Faces are All Blurred!
Eve Knew Her Apples: The Lady Eve on Blu-ray
  Guilty as Sin Objection!
Year: 1993
Director: Sidney Lumet
Stars: Rebecca De Mornay, Don Johnson, Stephen Lang, Jack Warden, Dana Ivey, Ron White, Norma Dell'Agnese, Sean McCann, Luis Guzmán, Robert Kennedy, James Blendick, Tom Butler, Christina Grace, Lynne Cormack, Barbara Eve Harris, Simon Sinn, Harvey Atkin
Genre: ThrillerBuy from Amazon
Rating:  5 (from 1 vote)
Review: Jennifer Haines (Rebecca De Mornay) is a successful lawyer in Chicago who gets to the heart of the cases she takes on with incisive intelligence and a willingness to defend her clients to the hilt, well, they are paying her a lot of money and those cases are often high profile. But during her latest session in the courtroom, where she once again blows a hole in the prosecution's accusations with evidence they cannot deny supplied by her professional cohort, the private detective and family friend Mo (Jack Warden), she notices that well-dressed man is in the public gallery once again. She doesn't know who he is, but he's always staring at her: does Jennifer have a fan? She finds out soon enough as David Greenhill (Don Johnson) is introduced...

Guilty as Sin represented a return to the courtroom genre for director Sidney Lumet, who back in the fifties made perhaps the greatest of them all in 12 Angry Men, but this has nowhere near the acclaim that classic did. In fact, many wondered what a director of his stature was doing with a script by Larry Cohen, a director himself who had spent the last decade making It's Alive sequels, Q the Winged Serpent and The Stuff, among others, not exactly the highest quality prestige efforts it would be fair to say. On the other hand, if you were a fan of trashier works such as that, your hopes may have been raised that Lumet would descend to Cohen's level and a fun ride would be on offer for fans of lurid thrillers.

Yet oddly, and this was odd, Lumet didn't approach it as Paul Verhoeven had Joe Eszterhas's script for Basic Instinct, the movie that had popularised the so-called erotic thrillers genre in the nineties, which was to turn up the volume on the most exploitative elements so that the results teetered on the edge of parody throughout. This wasn't even an erotic thriller at all, though that's how it was marketed, as Jennifer doesn't fall for Greenhill in the slightest, on the contrary she detests him from the minute she meets him to the finale, because she recognises him as a cunning manipulator who sees her as the best way to persuade a jury he has not pushed this wife out of a window recently. That's what he's accused of, and though Jennifer resists, that's what she has to defend him against.

Naturally, this started convoluted and stayed that way to the bitter end, but while Lumet could have had a lot of fun with this, what he actually did was present it with the utmost seriousness so that all the potential amusement was drained out of it. With its washed out, blue-tinted palette, Guilty as Sin was a disappointingly limp affair, and the fact that Jennifer and Greenhill did not have the complication of romance may have bucked a trend - she has a boyfriend (Stephen Lang) who sticks by her every step of the way, even at risk of personal injury - but also meant that there wasn't anything to steam up the screen. Johnson was obviously having fun as a psychopathic smoothie who keeps admitting terrible crimes to his lawyer as there's nothing she can do about it, but that fun wasn't infectious.

Or not as much as it should have been, at any rate. Every so often there was a glimmer of the romp it could have played out as, as when Greenhill makes a sandwich with maximum aggression while he essentially takes a stand for all the male equivalents of femmes fatales of which he believes himself to be one, but this was undercut by the way Jennifer wouldn't piss on him if he was on fire, which tended to sabotage his high opinion of his own abilities. Nevertheless, that point blank refusal for Jennifer to even slightly entertain the idea that her client might be interesting to have a fling with did make her a stronger, and let's face it, unusual character in this style of story, so much so that it was a little cheering to see the smug Greenhill won't get it all his own way. But there again was Lumet's insistence on conducting the material as sober as a judge when it needed a lot more oomph to set the pulse racing: for a thriller it was far too sedate, so when the ridiculous comeuppance occurs it looked to have arrived from a different movie entirely. Music by Howard Shore.
Reviewer: Graeme Clark


This review has been viewed 1393 time(s).

As a member you could Rate this film


Sidney Lumet  (1925 - 2011)

Esteemed American director who after a background in theatre moved into television from where he went on to be the five times Oscar nominated filmmaker behind some of the most intelligent films ever to come out of America. His 1957 debut for the big screen, 12 Angry Men, is still a landmark, and he proceeded to electrify and engross cinema audiences with The Fugitive Kind, The Pawnbroker, Cold War drama Fail-Safe, The Hill, The Group, The Deadly Affair, The Offence, definitive cop corruption drama Serpico, Murder on the Orient Express, Dog Day Afternoon (another great Al Pacino role), Network, Equus, Prince of the City, Deathtrap, The Verdict, Running On Empty and his final film, 2007's Before the Devil Knows You're Dead. Often working in the UK, he also brought his adopted home town of New York to films, an indelible part of its movies for the best part of fifty years.

Review Comments (0)

Untitled 1

Forgotten your details? Enter email address in Username box and click Reminder. Your details will be emailed to you.

Latest Poll
Which star is the best at shouting?
Arnold Schwarzenegger
Brian Blessed
Tiffany Haddish
Steve Carell
Olivia Colman
Captain Caveman
Sylvester Stallone
Gerard Butler
Samuel L. Jackson
Bipasha Basu

Recent Visitors
Graeme Clark
Paul Smith
Darren Jones
Andrew Pragasam
  Lee Fiveash
  Mick Stewart
Enoch Sneed
  Dsfgsdfg Dsgdsgsdg


Last Updated: