Newest Reviews
Black Water: Abyss
Wild Blue Yonder, The
All Hail the Popcorn King
Muriel, or the Time of Return
Great Locomotive Chase, The
American Anthem
Lion and the Horse, The
War of the Wizards
Doctor Faustus
Spite Marriage
Mask, The
Letter to Jane
Quick Millions
Dream Demon
Max Havelaar
Glastonbury Fayre
All Dogs Go to Heaven
Shoot Out
Da 5 Bloods
Kung Fu Monster
Secret Agent Super Dragon
Saint Frances
Boiling Point
Golden Stallion, The
Dragon Force
Anthropocene: The Human Epoch
Luck of Ginger Coffey, The
Junkers Come Here
White, White Day, A
Strong Medicine
Bitter Springs
Centipede Horror
Physical Evidence
Fanny Lye Deliver'd
Newest Articles
Bat-Damn: Was Joel Schumacher's Batman Really That Bad?
The Beat Goes On: Takeshi Kitano Collection on Blu-ray
Dream Treats: Scorsese Shorts on Blu-ray
It's Only Money: Laughter in Paradise on Blu-ray
A Regular Terpsichore: Dance, Girl, Dance on Blu-ray
Teenage Trauma: Baby Love on Blu-ray
The Happening: Pet Shop Boys It Couldn't Happen Here on Blu-ray
Who Watched The Watchmen?
The Golden Age of Colonic Irrigation: Monty Python Series 4 on Blu-ray
Lady of Pleasure: Lola Montes on Blu-ray
Take You to the Gay Bar: Funeral Parade of Roses on Blu-ray
Hit for Ms: Mark Cousins' Women Make Film on Blu-ray
Look Sinister: The 1000 Eyes of Dr. Mabuse on Blu-ray
Star Wars Triple Threat: The Tricky Third Prequel and Sequel
I Can See for Miles: The Man with the X-Ray Eyes on Blu-ray
Too Much Pressure: The Family Way on Blu-ray
The Alan Key: Alan Klein and What a Crazy World on Blu-ray
A Japanese Ghost Story: Kwaidan on Blu-ray
The Zu Gang: Zu Warriors from the Magic Mountain on Blu-ray
Reality TV: The Year of the Sex Olympics on DVD
The Young and the Damned: They Live By Night on Blu-ray
Mind How You Go: The Best of COI on Blu-ray
Der Kommissar's in Town: Babylon Berlin Series 3 on DVD
The End of Civilisation as We Know It: The 50th Anniversary
The Whalebone Box: The Andrew Kotting Interview
  Promise, A Romantic or Creepy?
Year: 2013
Director: Patrice Leconte
Stars: Rebecca Hall, Alan Rickman, Richard Madden, Maggie Steed, Shannon Tarbet, Toby Murray, Jean-Louis Sbille, Jonathan Sawdon, Christelle Cornil
Genre: Romance, HistoricalBuy from Amazon
Rating:  5 (from 1 vote)
Review: Germany, 1912. Friederich (Richard Madden), a young graduate of modest means, is engaged as a private secretary to ageing business magnate Karl Hoffmeister (Alan Rickman). When Hoffmeister falls ill he invites Friederich to stay at his house and handle his affairs whereupon the young man grows smitten with his employer's much younger wife, Charlotte (Rebecca Hall). At first Friederich struggles to hide his feelings but over time it becomes obvious Charlotte is in love with him too. A suspicious Hoffmeister sends Friederich to Mexico to oversee an iron mining operation. Before he leaves, Friederich makes Charlotte promise they will consummate their love upon his return. But in the wake of his departure comes the outbreak of the First World War.

Adapted from the novel "Journey into the Past" by Stefan Zweig, A Promise is the first film in the English language from French auteur Patrice Leconte. An excellent score by Gabriel Yared compliments Leconte's pacy visual style that prevents this becoming another starchy period piece. Yet despite a high calibre cast the love story never really catches fire. Part of the problem is the emotionally reticent Friederich who comes across as diffident, cold even calculating in parts. From the start he treats his working class girlfriend with barely concealed contempt, casting her aside mere minutes after sex before setting his sights on a more affluent quarry. There is something vaguely creepy about the manner in which Friederich inveigles his way into the Hoffmeister household, makes them come to depend on him and gradually usurps Karl's role as husband and father.

Of course none of this was intended to come across as creepy. It was meant to seem passionate and romantic. Yet in this instance the sensuality reoccurring from Leconte's previous tales of romantic obsession, e.g. The Hairdresser's Husband (1990) and Le Parfum d'Yvonne (1994), goes curiously awry. Instead of sharing Friederich's heartache one feels more than tad uneasy in scenes where he sniffs piano keys touched by Charlotte's hands or sneaks into her bedroom while she bathes in the room next door. One person's hopeless romantic is another person's stalker. Nevertheless the film does underline that while Charlotte is fond of her husband (who started out a family friend and helped her get over the death of her childhood sweetheart) she feels stifled being married to an older man. For his part Karl reacts to the growing closeness between Friederich and his wife with an ambiguous mix of subdued hostility and quiet resignation and Leconte comes across as equally uncertain as to how he wants us to feel about these events.

With no mention of politics or global events until the sound of a bell heralds the First World War, the film uncomfortably echoes La Vie en Rose (2007) in reducing a momentous historical tragedy to a blithe sub-plot while the conclusion briefly touches on the rise of Nazism. Much of the second act unfolds through love letters narrated by the leads as Charlotte endures both Friederich's absence and Karl's fading health. Just as Charlotte says the one thing that keeps her alive is the memory of Friederich's love, the only thing that retains viewer interest throughout this movie is Rebecca Hall's tireless performance. Otherwise it is a tepid romance that rambles on past its obvious conclusion without ever stirring the heart.

Reviewer: Andrew Pragasam


This review has been viewed 1055 time(s).

As a member you could Rate this film

Review Comments (0)

Untitled 1

Forgotten your details? Enter email address in Username box and click Reminder. Your details will be emailed to you.

Latest Poll
Which star is the best at shouting?
Arnold Schwarzenegger
Brian Blessed
Tiffany Haddish
Steve Carell
Olivia Colman
Captain Caveman
Sylvester Stallone
Gerard Butler
Samuel L. Jackson
Bipasha Basu

Recent Visitors
Graeme Clark
Paul Smith
Andrew Pragasam
Darren Jones
  Mick Stewart
Enoch Sneed
  Dsfgsdfg Dsgdsgsdg
  Hannah Prosser


Last Updated: