Newest Reviews
For the Sake of Vicious
Hell Bent
Straight Shooting
Jules Verne's Rocket to the Moon
Man They Could Not Hang, The
Final Days
Frightened City, The
Sequin in a Blue Room
Common Crime, A
Into the Labyrinth
Power, The
Wake of Death
Night Orchid
Iron Mask, The
Personal History of David Copperfield, The
Dove, The
Defending Your Life
Champagne Murders, The
He Dreams of Giants
Lost in America
Take Back
Banishing, The
Drifters, The
Gushing Prayer
Escape from Coral Cove
Swan Princess, The
Butterfly Murders, The
Lady is a Square, The
Newest Articles
Meiko Kaji's Girl Gangs: Stray Cat Rock on Arrow
Having a Wild Weekend: Catch Us If You Can on Blu-ray
The Drifters: Star Lucie Bourdeu Interview
Meiko Kaji Behind Bars: Female Prisoner Scorpion on Arrow
The Horror of the Soviets: Viy on Blu-ray
Network Double Bills: Tarka the Otter and The Belstone Fox
Network Double Bills: All Night Long and Ballad in Blue
Chew Him Up and Spit Him Out: Romeo is Bleeding on Blu-ray
British Body Snatchers: They Came from Beyond Space on Blu-ray
Bzzzt: Pulse on Blu-ray
The Tombs Will Be Their Cities: Demons and Demons 2 on Arrow
Somebody Killed Her Husband: Charade on Blu-ray
Network Double Bills: Maroc 7 and Invasion
Network Double Bills: The Best of Benny Hill and The Likely Lads
Network Double Bills: Some Girls Do and Deadlier Than the Male
Absolutely Bananas: Link on Blu-ray
Network Double Bills: Hawk the Slayer and The Medusa Touch
The Price of Plague: The Masque of the Red Death on Blu-ray
Network Double Bills: Seance on a Wet Afternoon and Ring of Spies
Chaney Chillers: Inner Sanctum Mysteries - The Complete Film Series on Blu-ray
Adelphi Extras: Stars in Your Eyes on Blu-ray
Toons for the Heads: Fantastic Planet and Adult Animation
Nature Girl: The New World on Blu-ray
Network Double Bills: Perfect Friday and Robbery
Network Double Bills: The House in Nightmare Park and The Man Who Haunted Himself
  If Beale Street Could Talk The White Man Is The Devil
Year: 2018
Director: Barry Jenkins
Stars: KiKi Layne, Stephan James, Regina King, Teyonah Paris, Colman Domingo, Ethan Barrett, Milanni Miles, Ebony Obsidian, Dominique Thorne, Michael Beach, Aunjanue Ellis, Diego Luna, Emily Rios, Ed Skrein, Finn Wittrock, Brian Tyree Henry, Dave Franco
Genre: DramaBuy from Amazon
Rating:  5 (from 1 vote)
Review: Tish Rivers (KiKi Layne) knew her boyfriend Fonny Hunt (Stephan James) since they were little kids, they had been friends, and as they matured grew closer until they became lovers recently. But while they were planning their life together, their optimism was cruelly dashed when Fonny was accused of rape by a woman in a different part of New York City where they lived, and he was sent behind bars until his trial, despite his protests of innocence. To complicate matters, Tish discovers soon after this that she is pregnant with Fonny's child, and goes to meet him to tell him so; he is alarmed at first, but then pleased, which is more than the reactions of his mother will be when she finds out...

When Barry Jenkins won an Oscar for Moonlight, it seemed like things were changing in Hollywood where an expressly African American story could walk home with the gongs rather than the more white-oriented movies that traditionally scored at such awards ceremonies. Whether it was overrated or justified, the fact remained it was a significant success, and great things were expected of this director. Therefore next, he aimed high and went for a literary adaptation, of James Baldwin's acclaimed nineteen-seventies novel If Beale Street Could Talk, which seemed set to make plain all of this filmmaker's concerns about race, relationships and injustice in America.

However, something happened from page to screen, and though Regina King (as Tish's mother) won an Oscar too, the movie may have been praised by the critics, but it failed to catch on with audiences. The reason for that was not so much the subject matter, though the fear they would be going to the theatres to be lectured for two hours cannot have helped, but it was more to do with Jenkins' technique: he simply came across as out of his depth, and no amount of pretty pictures and moody atmosphere could remedy that. If that were not bad enough, instead of being a vibrant, urgent story, once the narrative was established it turned excruciatingly boring for the rest of it.

Every so often there would be interludes where either Tish's voiceover or a montage of photographs would inform us of the injustice facing black people in the United States, mostly centring on the system that saw them routinely hassled by the police, or worse, placed in jails for crimes they might not have committed, or at least did not justify the harsh sentences meted out. Fair enough, the American prison system has its vocal critics, and black men are disproportionately represented inside, but if Jenkins wanted to make a documentary, then he should have done so, and yoking this to a love story that was not half as remarkable as he seemed to think it was did not make for a happy marriage between romance and social message-making. Worse, if you did not know the book, you would wonder what the fuss was about.

Passages from the text were lifted to be spoken by the cast, either as Tish's monologues or as exchanges in the dialogue, and they refused to fly, sounding artificial, even pretentious, which was fatal in a film that was purporting to be tackling real world issues. Although setting it in the seventies did not improve matters, yes it was faithful to the source, but it did not render the film as particularly current, and you may wish Jenkins had tweaked the script to make it more contemporary than just pointing at how it was like back then and expecting us to compare it to the twenty-first century, then nod sagely with an "Ahh..." of recognition. It was very carefully photographed (by James Laxton) and scored (by Nicholas Britell) to ooze class, all the better to bring out the tragedy, yet these looked like a distraction, and did not dispel the boredom which sabotaged the film at every turn. Such an emotive subject should have been vital and rousing, but this merely petered out with a non-ending. A huge disappointment.
Reviewer: Graeme Clark


This review has been viewed 711 time(s).

As a member you could Rate this film

Review Comments (0)

Untitled 1

Forgotten your details? Enter email address in Username box and click Reminder. Your details will be emailed to you.

Latest Poll
Which star probably has psychic powers?
Laurence Fishburne
Nicolas Cage
Anya Taylor-Joy
Patrick Stewart
Sissy Spacek
Michelle Yeoh
Aubrey Plaza
Tom Cruise
Beatrice Dalle
Michael Ironside

Recent Visitors
Graeme Clark
Andrew Pragasam
Darren Jones
Enoch Sneed
  Paul Tuersley
  Chris Garbutt
  Sdfadf Rtfgsdf
Stately Wayne Manor


Last Updated: