HOME |  JOIN |  CULT MOVIES | COMPETITIONS | ADVERTISE |  CONTACT US |  ABOUT US
 
 
Newest Reviews
Last Adventure, The
Secret Akko-Chan
Tickled
Revenge
Case of Hana & Alice, The
Ginseng King, The
It Was Fifty Years Ago Today! The Beatles: Sgt Pepper and Beyond
Cosh Boy
Comet in Moominland
Lazer Team
Passengers
Manchester by the Sea
Fire Force D.N.A. Sights 999.9
Zatoichi's Cane Sword
La La Land
Girl with All the Gifts, The
Captain Fantastic
Phantasm: Ravager
Borsalino
Science Ninja Team Gatchaman
Dead Heat
Killer Constable
Macross Frontier: The False Songstress
Operation Pink Squad II
Rapid Fire
Mystery of Picasso, The
Chinese Odyssey: Part Three, A
Swallows and Amazons
Kicks
Chandu the Magician
   
 
Newest Articles
And Then? 6 Hollywood Films That Should Have Had Sequels But Didn't
Approaching Menace: The Frighteners on DVD
Oz Factor: Strange Australia on the Cusp of the 80s
Dynamic Dozen: 80s Action in 12 Movies Part 2
Dynamic Dozen: 80s Action in 12 Movies Part 1
Manor On Movies: The Unguarded Moment (1956)
Manor On Movies: Curse Of The Dead (1961)
Q & A with San Francisco Silent Film Festival artistic director Anita Monga
Put Your Bigfoot In It: Bigfoot on Film
Maulin' the Jack: The Jack the Ripper Story Bastardized
   
 
  Once Upon a Time in America The Longest Guilt TripBuy this film here.
Year: 1984
Director: Sergio Leone
Stars: Robert De Niro, James Woods, Elizabeth McGovern, Joe Pesci, Burt Young, Tuesday Weld, Treat Williams, Danny Aiello, Richard Bright, James Hayden, William Forsythe, Darlanne Fluegel, Larry Rap, Richard Foronjy, Robert Harper, James Russo, Jennifer Connelly
Genre: Drama, Thriller
Rating:  7 (from 3 votes)
Review: Someone has called Noodles (Robert De Niro), who used to be a gangster in the 1930s, back to New York City, but he cannot work out who it might have been as he believed his past to be dead and buried, not to mention the people he remembers. The reason he had to flee all those years ago was that he had become involved with a potential crime, along with his buddies, which had ended up with all of them hunted down and killed by the authorities, all except for Noodles - even his girlfriend Eve (Darlanne Fluegel) was murdered. Now, in 1968, he will finally get to the heart of the mystery, but first he must track those who have survived from his memories...

A true labour of love that took years to reach the screen, Sergio Leone's final film was not well received at the time it was released, which only led to more ignominy for the epic as it was recut to a shorter length, something which either turned off the fans who might have appreciated the full version or confused those who were not going to enjoy it in whatever form it arrived in anyway. Now we can see it as it was intended to be seen, nearly four hours of gangsters coming to terms with their failings, which for some is one of the greatest films ever made. However, this does not quite prevent some naysayers pointing out that even in its longer cut, there's a lot about this that is plain awkward.

If Once Upon a Time in America is not quite a curate's egg, one wonders if its flaws would have been quite as forgiven if this had been made by a director with lesser cultural standing. There's no faulting Leone's ambition, as he was to be admired as one of the few filmmakers who would even have considered bringing such a mélange of diverse scenes to the screen as one coherent entity, and in truth coherence was not its strong point. For every shocking sequence of violence or moving recognition of what Noodles has lost through his follies, there is a poorly judged try at making a statement or bringing all the time periods it concentrates on together, which often leaves the plot in tangles.

This renders the film a remote experience, as while you can appreciate the hard work that went into creating it, it's not always the most emotionally satisfying of stories. Leone edited it so that we flit backwards and forwards in time, from Noodles' childhood in a Jewish neighbourhood where he learned the tricks of the criminal trade with his friends, right up to the late sixties where he will at last get the answers to all those questions that have been bothering him all these years - better late then never, one assumes. The bulk of the narrative takes place in the early thirties where Noodles gets out of prison and joins with the bootlegging operation of Max (James Woods), his closest relationship but one which will bring about tragedy not only for them both, but too many others as well.

However, Noodles always hoped his closest relationship would be with the girl from his neighbourhood who he idolised, Deborah, played as an adult by Elizabeth McGovern in a dog of a role as she has to essay the woman of his dreams, while being both the movie star she aspires to be and ending up savaged by his impossible to suppress evil, which naturally forces her away for good. The male cast fare better, but curiously even with this amount of time to play with they never get a hang of their characters and rarely offer stellar performances; funnily enough only Tuesday Weld as the masochistic Carol truly convinces, perhaps because the women get such a raw deal from the men here and she seems the best survivor. Really this is about betrayal, not only for the friendships, but for the way that nostalgia is corrupted by death and the tendency of bad memories to surface, romance ends with rape from Noodles, and high ideals are always brought low by someone else's immorality - or your own. The final scene suggesting it was all a dream doesn't do this any favours, but it's a fascinating failure for all that. Music by Ennio Morricone.
Reviewer: Graeme Clark

 

This review has been viewed 2269 time(s).

As a member you could Rate this film

 
Review Comments (2)


Untitled 1

Login
  Username:
 
  Password:
 
   
 
Forgotten your details? Enter email address in Username box and click Reminder. Your details will be emailed to you.
   

Latest Poll
Who's the best?
Bernard Cribbins
Tom Cruise
   
 
   

Recent Visitors
Andrew Pragasam
Paul Shrimpton
Graeme Clark
Enoch Sneed
  Rachel Franke
  Desbris M
Stately Wayne Manor
Keith Rockmael
   

 

Last Updated: