HOME |  JOIN |  CULT MOVIES | COMPETITIONS | ADVERTISE |  CONTACT US |  ABOUT US
 
 
Newest Reviews
Limehouse Golem, The
Frankenstein '80
Good Time
Bucket of Blood, A
Detroit
Hide and Seek
What Happened to Monday
River Wild, The
Veteran
Slumber Party '57
Juliette, or Key of Dreams
Summertime Killer
Sweet Virginia
Ben & Arthur
Your Name
Red Hot Shot, The
New World
Trick Baby
Weapons of Death
Second Best Secret Agent in the Whole Wide World, The
Kills on Wheels
Strait-Jacket
This Man is Dangerous
Burning Paradise
Away
Mistress of the Apes
Incredible Paris Incident
Star Wars: The Last Jedi
Fox and His Friends
Bitter Harvest
   
 
Newest Articles
Movie Flop to Triumphant TV Revival: Twin Peaks and The League of Gentlemen
Driving Force: The Golden Age of American Car Chases
Madness in his Method: Jim Carrey and Andy Kaufman
Music, Love and Flowers: Monterey Pop on Blu-ray
The Melville Mood: His Final Two Films on The Melville Collection Blu-ray
Always Agn├Ęs: 3 from The Varda Collection Blu-ray
Re: Possession of Vehicles - Killer Cars, Trucks and a Vampire Motorcycle
The Whicker Kicker: Whicker's World Vols 5&6 on DVD
The Empress, the Mermaid and the Princess Bride: Three 80s Fantasy Movies
Witching Hour: Hammer House of Horror on Blu-ray
   
 
  Black Dahlia, The Film Noir FiascoBuy this film here.
Year: 2006
Director: Brian De Palma
Stars: Josh Hartnett, Scarlett Johansson, Aaron Eckhart, Hilary Swank, Mia Kirshner, Mike Starr, Fiona Shaw, Patrick Fischler, James Otis, John Kavanagh, Troy Evans, Anthony Russell, Pepe Serna, Angus MacInnes, Rachel Miner, Rose McGowan, Gregg Henry
Genre: Thriller, Historical
Rating:  4 (from 1 vote)
Review: Dwight "Bucky" Bleichert (Josh Hartnett) used to be a boxer, so when a fundraiser in the Los Angeles police force where he works comes up, he agrees to put the gloves back on and fight fellow cop (and ex-boxer) Lee Blanchard (Aaron Eckhart). He might lose his pride - and a couple of teeth - but the match is a success and the two men are promoted to the homicide department while Bucky gets to put his ailing father in a rest home. Then one day, they are performing routine police work when a gunfight breaks out - yet nearby, on a patch of wasteground is a case that will ruin both of them.

Judging from the lonely trumpet of Mark Isham's score, The Black Dahlia was meant to be director Brian De Palma's Chinatown, and in a way it was in that he would have been best to forget it. Josh Friedman adapted James Ellroy's minor modern classic crime novel, but he, like De Palma and most of the cast, allowed the complex material to get away from them. The real Black Dahlia was Elizabeth Short, wannabe starlet and victim of one of the most gruesome murders of the 1940s, and Ellroy's book was a version of events that provided a solution to the actually unsolved case.

In the film, there are changes as there often are with novel-to-screen journeys, but none of them are alterations for the better. The body found on the wasteground is Short's, horribly mutilated, and being homicide cops Bucky and Lee are put on the case. There was an opportunity here for an exploration of how the most disturbing sides to police work can have detrimental effects on the people investigating them, but that would require more depth than this film is comfortable with as it's all they can do to keep the twists of the plot understandable.

It was a film with troubles in its development, yet many big screen works succeed despite the conditions they were made under which doesn't really happen here. To its credit, and as expected with De Palma, techincally it is very proficient with a sepia-hued nineteen-forties world at least looking the part. But the cast never look the part, there's too much of the dressing up box about most of them and Hartnett remains oddly leaden throughout. Not to mention the air of dread and violence taken from the novel dies away after the first few scenes.

So you're left with a collection of beautifully photographed sequences that don't fall into place when strung together. Scarlett Johansson play's Lee's live in girlfriend, a prostitute he saved, but is too mannered one minute, too muted the next. Hilary Swank is a strange choice for femme fatale Madeleine, especially as she's supposed to be the image of Short, but as Short is played by Mia Kirshner the suspension of disbelief quickly evaporates when it's plain they look nothing like each other. Then there are the grotesque scenes with rich girl Madeleine's family which might have fit well into a comedy of embarrassment: Fiona Shaw as the mother ludicrously overacts and her final bit of business near the end is absolutely hilarious. Another Ellroy adaptation, L.A. Confidential, found a way to succeed by making up its own story from the bare bones of the novel, but The Black Dahlia fumbles, never settling into a satisfying style.
Reviewer: Graeme Clark

 

This review has been viewed 2894 time(s).

As a member you could Rate this film

 

Brian De Palma  (1940 - )

Controversial American director and Alfred Hitchcock fan, strong on style, but weak on emotion. His early, political films like Greetings and Hi, Mom! gained some acclaim, but it was with Sisters that he emerged as a major talent of the 1970s and settled into his cycle of thrillers and horrors: The Phantom of the Paradise, Carrie, Obsession, The Fury, Dressed to Kill, Blow Out, Body Double, Carlito's Way, Raising Cain, Snake Eyes and Femme Fatale being good examples.

He's not aversed to directing blockbusters such as Scarface, The Untouchables and Mission Impossible, but Bonfire of the Vanities was a famous flop and The Black Dahlia fared little better as his profile dipped in its later years, with Passion barely seeing the inside of cinemas. Even in his poorest films, his way with the camera is undeniably impressive. Was once married to Nancy Allen.

 
Review Comments (0)


Untitled 1

Login
  Username:
 
  Password:
 
   
 
Forgotten your details? Enter email address in Username box and click Reminder. Your details will be emailed to you.
   

Latest Poll
Who's the best?
Robin Askwith
Mark Wahlberg
   
 
   

Recent Visitors
Graeme Clark
Andrew Pragasam
Paul Shrimpton
  Rachel Franke
Jason Cook
Enoch Sneed
Darren Jones
Keith Rockmael
   

 

Last Updated: