Newest Reviews
Black Panther
Children's Hour, The
Guyver, The
Night School
Mishima: A Life in Four Chapters
Murders in the Rue Morgue
Wound, The
Let's Get Harry
Girl with Green Eyes
Sunchaser, The
Tom Jones
Defiant Ones, The
Centerfold Girls, The
Loneliness of the Long Distance Runner, The
120 BPM (Beats Per Minute)
Police Academy 3: Back in Training
Safe Place, A
Saturday Night and Sunday Morning
Entertainer, The
Wing Commander
Look Back in Anger
Early Man
Newest Articles
A Yen for the 1990s: Iron Monkey and Satan Returns
Hey, Punk: Jubilee and Rock 'n' Roll High School
Help! with The Knack: Richard Lester in 1965
Roll Up, Get Yer Free Cinema: The Shorts on the BFI Woodfall Blu-rays
Time for Heroes: The Dam Busters and How I Won the War
Hell is a City: Midnight Cowboy and Taxi Driver
Boris Goes Bonkers, Bela Goes Bats: The Old Dark House and Mark of the Vampire
Charles Bronson's Mid-70s: Breakheart Pass and Others
Kids in America: The Breakfast Club vs Metropolitan
80s Dance-Off: Staying Alive vs Murder-Rock vs Breakin'
The Cinematic Darkside of Donald Crowhurst
Dutch Courage: The Flodder Series
Coming of Age: Boys on Film 18 - Heroes on DVD
Country and Irish - The secret history of Irish pop culture
Wash All This Scum Off the Streets: Vigilante Movies
  Student and Mister Henri, The Life lessons from an old grumpBuy this film here.
Year: 2016
Director: Ivan Calbérac
Stars: Claude Brasseur, Guillaume de Tonquédec, Noémie Schmidt, Frédérique Bel, Thomas Solivérès, Valérie Kéruzoré, Stéphan Wojtowicz, Antoine Glemain, Grégori Baquet, Anne Loiret
Genre: Comedy
Rating:  6 (from 1 vote)
Review: Constance Pipponier (Noémie Schmidt), a struggling college student, thinks her desperate search for an apartment in Paris is finally at an end when she rents a room from curmudgeonly old Henri Voizot (Claude Brasseur). Already burdened with studying for exams and pressure from her parents, she tries to abide by Henri's absurdly fastidious house rules but somehow lands on his wrong side. To avoid being thrown out on the street, Constance rashly agrees to assist Henri in a spiteful scheme to lure his forty-something son Paul (Guillaume de Tonquédec) away from his shrill, overbearing wife Valérie (Frédérique Bel). Needless to say, as things grow increasingly complicated Constance comes to regret that decision.

Adapted from a hit stage comedy by Ivan Calbérac, who won a César award for his screen debut Iréne (2002), L'Étudiante et Monsieur Henri (The Student and Mister Henri) drew flak from critics who compared it unfavourably with Claude Sautet's much-beloved Nelly and Monsieur Arnaud (1995), another French character study pairing a grumpy old man with a lovely young woman. It is certainly not in that league but critics unfairly lumped this together with films like The Players (2012), Amour & Turbulences (2013) Family for Rent (2015), Blind Date (2015) and Up for Love (2016) as further proof of the decline of French comedy into cod-Hollywood froth. That is simply not the case with Calbérac's film at all. Grounded in nuanced characters and painfully relatable human foibles, it has depth and melancholy. The chemistry between skilled veteran Claude Brasseur and newcomer Noémie Schmidt, a beguiling ingenue of the sort only the French film industry seems able to consistently reproduce year after year, is natural and engaging enough to gloss over the odd awkward moment in the transfer from stage to screen.

Much like the popular Gérard Depardieu vehicle from yesteryear: Mon Père Ce Héros (1991), The Student and Mister Henri turns a potentially offensive premise into the stuff of light, surprisingly warm and humane farce. Even so the spine of Calbérac's story remains the slow thaw in the relationship between two flawed, sympathetic characters who grow to learn something from each other. He is grumpy and embittered. She is feisty and forthright and does not take any guff from the old so-and-so. It is an old, familiar tale but plays out with more pathos and naturalism than that description might suggest. Also to the film's credit the subplot dealing with Constance and her struggle to find her place in the world does not sugar-coat the adversity and tough decisions young people face in order to grow. Her setbacks at college, frustration with a family seemingly indifferent to her gifts and aspirations along with a propensity for foolish flings with exploitative middle-aged substitute father figures, all ring painfully true.

Typically for a French comedy the film somehow gets away with glossing over more troublesome aspects like the age-difference between Constance and Paul along with faintly icky undertones of sexual exploitation. In fact Paul is portrayed as a caring, sweet-natured, self-deprecating soul, nothing at all like his sour old man albeit a trifle buttoned-down. Most of the laughs stem from Paul's flustered reaction to this unexpected attention from an attractive young woman and later his cringe-worthy attempt to party with kids half his age. However, Calbérac wisely takes pains to establish a solid motive for Constance to play along with Henri's reprehensible plan and still remain sympathetic. Grace moments of humanity elevate the material: e.g. Henri's wistful reaction when Constance reveals her talent for playing the piano. This turn of events sparks a streak of altruism in the old grump, though while the experience spurs Constance to stand up to her dad, the film fumbles the lesson Henri needed to learn about respecting the life choices of young people.

Reviewer: Andrew Pragasam


This review has been viewed 381 time(s).

As a member you could Rate this film

Review Comments (0)

Untitled 1

Forgotten your details? Enter email address in Username box and click Reminder. Your details will be emailed to you.

Latest Poll
Which film has the best theme song?
The Ups and Downs of a Handyman

Recent Visitors
Graeme Clark
Enoch Sneed
Paul Smith
  Jamie Nichols
Andrew Pragasam
George White
Darren Jones
  Butch Elliot


Last Updated: